A Retrospective Ranking of All 16 REM Albums for Their 40th Anniversary

To commemorate the 40th anniversary of REM’s album *Fables of the Reconstruction*, Alexis Petridis offers an in-depth ranking of the band’s complete discography, analyzing the evolution of their sound, lyrical themes, and critical reception over time. The ranking places *Automatic for the People* (1992) at the top, citing its dark tone and unexpected influences, while *Around the Sun* (2004) comes in last due to its lifelessness and lack of engagement, even according to the band itself. Petridis considers *Murmur* (1983) and *Lifes Rich Pageant* (1986) standout albums for their innovation and songwriting quality. Albums like *Monster* (1994) and *New Adventures in Hi-Fi* (1996) are praised for their rawness and emotional complexity, despite being made during tumultuous periods. The review acknowledges commercial highs such as *Out of Time* (1991) and transitional efforts like *Up* (1998) and *Reveal* (2001), reflecting on the band’s experimentation with electronics after the departure of drummer Bill Berry. Even lesser-loved records like *Collapse Into Now* and *Accelerate* are recognized for their attempt to recapture REM’s signature energy. The article offers a comprehensive and thoughtful look at one of alternative rock’s most enduring bands.